How to Not Ask for a Warm Intro — And Still Get One

Why Asking for Warm Intros Usually Fails

If you’ve ever tried to get a warm introduction into a target account, you’ve probably run into one (or all) of these problems:

• The connector barely knows the prospect — especially true if you’re relying on LinkedIn 1st-degree connections.

• Too many steps — from crafting the request to getting the final response, it can take days (or weeks).

• Low success rate — and even when you get the intro, it doesn’t guarantee a meeting.

• You’re burning social capital — and often feel obligated to return the favor later.

Here’s what the process typically looks like:

1. Identify someone who knows your target

2. Draft your ask

3. Find their contact info

4. Send the intro request

5. Wait for their reply

6. Hope they’re willing

7. Wait for the prospect to opt in

8. Finally get looped in

9. Follow up

10. Now owe a favor

That’s a lot of work for a maybe.

MoxieGTM is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Real-World Test: Asking vs. Referencing

We tested this strategy with a Series C software company.

Test A: Traditional Warm Intro Ask

• Reached out to executives asking for intros to key prospects.

• Took 2 weeks to get responses

• Most replies said “I don’t know them well enough”

• Result: Not repeatable. Minimal ROI.

Test B: Referencing Users in Cold Emails

• Used names of power users as social proof in outbound emails.

• Campaign was live in 1 week

• In 24 hours: 4% reply rate, 2% booked meetings

• Easy to repeat. High return on effort.

The Winning Cold Email Template

This outbound message consistently booked meetings by not asking for an intro:

“Hi {{FirstName}} – Noticed you crossed paths with [Connector]. [Connector] is one of the most active users of our RevOps tool. Open to learning how [Connector] uses us to improve forecasting?”

It’s short. It’s social. And it works.

Turn Users into Referrers — Without Lifting a Finger

This strategy scales because your product does the heavy lifting.

Your happy customers become your best sales assets — even if they never send an intro email.

Here’s how to replicate it:

1. Identify power users (LinkedIn, product usage, or NPS)

2. Mention them in outbound emails

3. Run micro-campaigns around different user cohorts

4. Track results and iterate

You can get results in less than 2 weeks.

Want Help Setting This Up?

We’re running a free pilot program for three startups looking to turn their users into referrers.

DM me or reply to this post if you’re interested.

Also: check out my interview with Andrew McGuire where we break this tactic down in detail using The Swarm 🔆’s referral API.

Subscribe to MoxieGTM

By Richard F. Purcell · Launched 2 years ago

The newsletter for the busiest, most sophisticated GTM leaders. Discover step-by-step instructions for implementing unconventional GTM experiments, drawn directly from the operators who ran each campaign.

By subscribing, I agree to Terms of Use, and acknowledge its Information Collection Notice and Privacy Policy.